Wednesday, July 25, 2018

DUTTON DYNASTY DOCUMENTS DELIVER ODD COURT CASE

 Calcutta   link  to  South Australian  poison  plot !!!

Included in the pile of old  documents  from the  Dutton family  homestead, Anlaby , at Kapunda , South  Australia ,  were  some  relating to an investment opportunity in Papua Plantations Limited , the  chairman of directors of  which  was   Stephen  S.  Ralli . Another director , R. T. Melrose , may have been in partnership  with   H. H. Dutton  in a Morgan pastoral property .  Of  all  the many people mentioned  in  the  collection , Ralli  was selected  to  follow up  , and   hit  an  unexpected  jackpot .
 
 By Peter Simon
 
A search of the  National Library of  Australia  newspaper Trove  turned up a unique 1902  court  case  involving  Ralli, owner of  Weracata Station , Balaclava, South Australia . He was  charged  with  a  breech of  the  law pertaining to the import  of a   small quantity of pure  mustard  oil   from  India , ordered  through an agent , worth  two  shillings  and  eightpence , not  30 cents , the duty on which  would  have  been  sixpence , five cents  .
 
The  four tins in  which the  oil came ,  each containing slightly more than a pint ,   attracted  attention  when  it  was  noticed  that  Jail  was  printed on them . The court  documents  said  it had been produced  at  His Majesty's Presidency  Gaol, Calcutta , India .   The  newspaper  report   explained    mustard  oil  was  said  to  be  very  efficacious  in sickness.
 
Ralli  pleaded not guilty and was  defended by  Mr A. W. Piper   who obviously thought  the   charge  was  absurd , describing  the  hearing   as  being " like a  French court . " Nevertheless , the Crown Solicitor , Mr J. M. Stuart , was a  high powered  King's Counsel.  
 
Under cross examination , a Customs Officer, with  29 years' experience , said it was  the first time he had  known mustard oil  to be impounded . Further  more , the officer agreed he had never been   to Calcutta, been inside  the   prison  mentioned  in   the    charge , nor  had  he  ever been  inside   any  other  gaol .
 
Piper   pounced on the witness , "Then you have never known  Ralli to threaten  to  poison  all  of  South Australia , have you ? "  Laughter  ensued    in  the courtroom . No , was the reply .  The sympathetic bench decided to  cut  the mustard frivolity by   imposing  the lowest  fine possible , five pounds , and  did  not  impose  costs . Wonder if  Stephen   Ralli  , apparently interested in early automobiles , was  related to the   rich  Greek  Ralli  Brothers  dynasty which  had  widespread   interests  in commerce , banking , produce  in   Russia, India  Britain , America   and   elsewhere ?