Saturday, January 14, 2017

DOCTOR INVOLVED IN MAJOR WHISTLEBLOWER CASE

Dr  Pauline  Wilson   AM    who   died   recently in  Darwin  was  involved in an interesting  case  involving  outspoken  activist  doctor  , Philip Nitschke , who  later  became   internationally  known   for   his   euthanasia   advocacy .  

For  many  years  she   was   the  Royal   Darwin  Hospital medical superintendent  and  became  a   key  player  in   the whistleblower    episode   which  resulted  in   a Senate  inquiry   into a   claim     that  Dr   Nitschke    had   suffered   possible  penalty  or  injury   as  the result  of having been a  witness    before   the    Standing Committee on  Industry, Science, Technology , Transport , Communications   and   Infrastracture, resulting in contempt of  the committee.

Briefly, in  1993 , he  got into  hot  water. Speaking    for  the  Medical Association for the Prevention of  War , during the  visit of  the  USS  Houston   to Darwin , he  said the  Royal Darwin Hospital  (RDH) could not cope with a nuclear accident,  his  views said to  have  caused  great disquiet  to  senior management .The  Senate report   said  he had  been " vigorously "  reminded  of  the  guidelines governing all  public servants  .

However, the NT Health Department acknowledged inadequacies in the Royal  Darwin Hospital  protocols for dealing  with nuclear ship visits  and  Dr Nitschke's   contribution  . 


 Later , giving  a lecture sponsored by the NT  Branch of  the  Public Health Association , entitled  Public health and private conscience : whistleblowing and its impact on health,  given to the Menzies  School of  Health Research, he again mentioned  the   RDH   nuclear protocols  and   discussed    the needle  exchange situation  .

 An ABC radio interview   upset the  NT Minister for Health and Community  Services , Mike Reed , of  Katherine, who supported the RDH  needle exchange and    said   the   doctor  seemed unable to  come to  grips with the fact that public health policy was not set by him but by the NT Government and the Health and Community Services  Department . If he could not cope with this fact of  life , he  could  go .  Dr Wilson asked  Dr  Nitschke   for a  written explanation , which she subsequently accepted .

 The  explanation    was  supplemented by  a letter from the Public Health  Association   NT   branch , outlining the  circumstances of the lecture  and expressing disappointment  that RDH  had  started an investigation of  the  doctor.     A     proposal   by  some within   hospital management   to  discipline   Dr  Nitschke  by  failing  to   conduct a  first round  interview   for renewal of  a  six month  contract  did  not  go  ahead.  However , life was  made  difficult  for  him  ,  he  departed   in  1994 .  The  committee   failed to find that  there had  been  any  contempt  due  to  Dr  Nitschke  having   given  evidence  before   it .

 It  went  on  to say that it would be  especially worthwhile  if a remedy could  follow " from  those who  have  punished  Dr Nitschke  for  exercising  what should be  his right as a  citizen , as a representative of a  community organisation  and  as an informed    professional to state publicly his medical opinions ."  
 
NEXT: Little  Darwin's sometimes smelly connection with  Dr  Wilson's  champion   wayward   dog .